dcsimg
You are here:

College "Meritocracy" Stirs Debate

An excellent forum for the discussion of traditional college admission and graduation progress can be found in the Forbes Magazine section on America's best colleges. While the rankings are traditional, some of the commentary is not. Guest columns in this issue raise the issue of the selection process practiced by the nation's finest schools and the real value of the process.

Two law professors - one from Harvard, one at Columbia - co-wrote an editorial that challenges the elite nature of student selection among highly ranked schools in the nation. Their argument is that the test scores and grades traditionally used to evaluate admission applications are not necessarily predictive of a student's ability to thrive in the college environment.

Their argument is that the "testocracy" stratifies students by race and class. Referring to Harvard, they comment that, "Selective colleges and universities, like this one, act more like consumers than producers of merit. They build their reputation based on the credentials of the people they admit rather than the contributions of the people they graduate."

Some colleges are moving away from evaluating students simply on test scores and grades, looking for a more three dimensional image of the applicant than can be provided simply by SAT scores. The article notes that at least 800 institutions have broadened their admission criteria, seeking to find "��students who would be most transformed by their educational experience."

Mr. Sperling makes a good case for the open enrollment approach of the for-profit, accredited online schools. Applicants who land in these institutions want to be there to enrich their academic backgrounds and their career options. Moreover, says Sperling, the millions of would-be students who cannot meet fixed class schedules have an alternative in distance learning that is quickly becoming a valid educational alternative and one that should be actively supported by the U.S. Department of Education.

President Obama's call for an enormous expansion in college attendance is going to require contributions from every quarter, he argues. The innovation found in online institutions and their open enrollment policies are an essential element in meeting the goal of having the highest percentage of college graduates among all the world's nations by the year 2020.

Search Schools

      
Matching School Ads
  • University of Maryland at College Park

    Study online with University of Maryland at College Park.

    Programs

    • MBA - Information Systems & Business Analytics
    • MBA - General
    • MBA - Marketing
    • More...
    Location:
    College Park: , College Park MD 20742
    University of Maryland at College Park Request Info »
  • Tulane University - School of Social Work

    There is no more exciting time to be part of the renowned Tulane School of Social Work or of the intriguing city of New Orleans than at this moment. 

    Programs

    • Masters in Social Work

    Location: Online

    Tulane University - School of Social Work Request Info »
  • Washington State University

    Get your career started with training from Washington State University.

    Programs

    • Executive MBA
    • MBA
    Location:
    Pullman: , Pullman WA
    Washington State University Request Info »
  • Penn Foster

    Advance your career with our affordable, self-paced, career-focused distance education programs.

    Programs

    • Home Health Aide
    • Security Guard
    • Veterinary Assistant
    • More...
    Location:
    Scranton: , Scranton PA 18515
    Penn Foster Request Info »
  • George Mason University

    Located in Fairfax, Virginia, George Mason University is the largest public research university in the Commonwealth of Virginia.

    Programs

    • Master of Education in Special Education, specializing in Applied Behavior Analysis
    • Master of Business Administration: Business Analytics Specialization
    • Master of Education in Special Education, specializing in Autism Spectrum Disorder
    • More...

    Location: Online

    George Mason  University Request Info »
  • Liberty University

    100% Online & No Standardized Testing

    Programs

    • Doctor of Education: Community Care & Counseling: Marriage & Family
    • Doctor of Ministry: Evangelism & Church Planting
    • M.Div: Homiletics
    • More...
    Location:
    Lynchburg: 1971 University Blvd,, Lynchburg VA 24515
    Liberty University Request Info »
  • South University, Online Programs

    As a student at South University, Online Programs you will receive the same quality instruction, variety of learning options and level of service found at the campus locations.

    Programs

    • Nurse Educator (PGC)
    • Nursing (RN to BSN)
    • Specialization in Nursing Informatics (RN to MSN)
    • More...
    Location:
    Savannah: 709 Mall Boulevard, Savannah GA 31406
    South University, Online Programs Request Info »
  • Colorado State University-Global Campus

    Colorado State University-Global Campus

    Colorado State University-Global Campus (CSU-Global) offers career relevant bachelor’s and master’s degree programs for working adults and nontraditional learners.

    Programs

    • MS - Data Analytics
    • Bachelors in Business Management
    • Graduate Specialization - Accounting
    • More...
    Location:
    Englewood: 7800 E Orchard Rd,, Englewood CO 80111
    Colorado State University-Global Campus Request Info »
  • University of Southern California - DSW

    The University of Southern California Doctor of Social Work (DSW) online program is designed for experienced practitioners to harness innovative solutions to solve real-world problems.

    Unlike a PhD in social work, which prepares scholars for careers in research and the professoriate, the DSW@USC is an online advanced practice degree program for working professionals who want to have a greater impact in their practice.

    Programs

    • Doctor of Social Work (DSW)
    Location:
    Los Angeles: 669 W 34th St, Los Angeles CA 90089
    University of Southern California - DSW Request Info »
  • Rocky Mountain College of Art + Design

    RMCAD - Where Your Creativity Comes to Life

     

    Programs

    • Graphic Design Online
    • Illustration Online
    • Game Art Online
    • More...

    Location: Online

    Rocky Mountain College of Art + Design Request Info »
  • Matching School Ads

    Quick School Search

    College & Career Search Tools

    • Careers: Unsure about your career path? Study profiles of hundreds of professions.

    • Interviews: Professors and deans sit down with our team to give you unique insights on college life.

    • Military Education: Find only Military friendly online schools and campuses.

    • Student Reviews: Know before you go. Read student reviews on over 2000 accredited colleges. Write your own experience.